Kind and Wicked Domains, and Volleyball

Arguments exist about the presence of kind (highly rule-bound) and wicked domains. Fields such as golf, chess, and classical music are the former while basketball, warfare, and politics would fall into the latter. Kind domains give immediate feedback allowing deliberate practice on skills applied to patterns. Wicked domains inform more random events. 

Volleyball has a relatively simple set of rules. Exceptional players are not  "rule-bound" but improvise, like jazz.  

Volleyball’s Dual Nature

On the surface, volleyball looks like a kind domain:

• The court is measured, the ball and net are standardized.

• Rotations, touches, scoring, and boundaries are tightly rule-bound.

• Skills can be drilled endlessly with clear cause-and-effect feedback (serving errors, hitting percentage, blocking touches).

But once competition starts, volleyball takes on a wicked character:

• Dynamic interactions: Unlike golf or tennis singles, every point is a six-on-six negotiation. The ball can be attacked in countless ways, with timing, angle, and deception constantly shifting.

• Uncertain feedback: A well-executed set may be blocked. A poorly formed dig might ricochet perfectly for a kill. Effort ≠ outcome in any simple way.

• Opponent-driven adaptation: Teams adjust defensive schemes, blockers “read” hitters, servers target weak passers. Each adjustment begets a counter-adjustment.

• Improvisation under constraint: Broken plays (off-system balls, scrambles) often determine outcomes. Exceptional players succeed by inventing solutions on the fly—more like jazz than classical performance.

Volleyball as Jazz, Not Sheet Music

• Classical analogy (kind domain): A violinist in an orchestra must execute notes as written, just as a volleyball player must master serves, passes, and spikes.

• Jazz analogy (wicked domain): Great volleyball resembles a jam session—players riff within a structure, responding to what others do in real time. A setter improvises tempo or location; a hitter adjusts midair; defenders anticipate rather than react.

The Argument for Wickedness

Volleyball appears kind but reveals wickedness. It blends rule-bound skills with emergent complexity. Players who only master the “rules” (mechanics, drills) plateau. The greats—think Karch Kiraly, Giba, Jordan Larson—are improvisers, constantly making reads and creating advantages out of chaos.

In other words: volleyball is not chess on a court—it’s jazz in motion.

• Servers can increase complexity with placement, topspin, sidespin, or combinations. 
• Setters make decisions to play the two-ball for winners or to keep balls from going into the net. 
• Attackers read defenses quicker and alter the attack.
• Defenders make plays with one-arm, pancakes, or even kick the ball alive. 

Lagniappe. Become the best version of yourself.